See also Steep
Powered Paragliding on Spirals and Wingovers.
Staying alive while paramotoring has proven quite simple: don't
do the things listed here. Overall, the risk can be made extremely
small.
Most accidents happen for predictable and
preventable causes. Avoid them. Water and turbulence are the bugaboos in
that order. If water landing is a possibility, carry floatation (like
Agama). If you fly where turbulence is a possibility, carry a reserve
AND KNOW HOW TO USE IT! But don't think that carrying a reserve makes turbulence
safe -- most turbulence-related fatalities happened below safe
deployment height. All the turbulence related fatalities happened in air the pilot
knew was likely to be turbulent. One more thing: wear a helmet, that
would have prevented at least one fatality.
We don't address the largest cause of
serious injuries: prop strikes. That's because, so far, they have proven survivable
albeit with sometimes permanent disability.
Training
Yes, I'm afraid the training phase carries elevated risk though
nothing as dramatic as self training. We don't always hear of the
fatalities that relate to truck towing--when some bubba gets a
paraglider on eBay, ties himself to a truck and tells his buddy to punch
it. That rarely goes well.
Much of my drive to improve training methods (i.e. use of
the USPPA syllabus) stems from this sad fact. We can never eliminate
the risk, but some of these can easily be avoided by changing common
practice.
1996, New York, Solo Student with less than 5 flights is practicing
flying. The instructor was working with at least two students at the time when he
noticed one of them spinning from several hundred feet. It was late
morning with probably level
2 or 3 level
turbulence. He spun into trees then fell to his death. Probable
cause: excessive brake that caused the glider to spin. Turbulence alone
doesn't cause spins—heavy braking does.
2006, Student under tow using a turn-around pulley. Gets off line.
Instructor commands a turn while letting off the tow pull but it was too
late. The student locked out and hit hard.
Steep Maneuvering
1996, France, Experienced pilot with probably several hundred
flights.
Pilot suffered a collapse and spin without enough altitude to recover. He
was on a competition wing which aggravates matters since its long,
skinny wings are more likely to fold up and more finicky in the
recovery.
2001, Toledo, Ohio, Experienced pilot with several hundred
flights.
Wally Shilts was known to do frequently steep maneuvering and, on one
particularly aggressive wing over, he went loose on the lines then
didn't have enough altitude to complete the recovery. He ended up
hitting the ground. He was flying mid-day so its likely that turbulence
could have been a factor.
2010, Galveston, Texas, Experienced pilot
doing steep spirals.
Mike Larronde liked steep, but not usually nose-over (vertical), spirals
with a low recovery. While doing this with a different wing than normal,
he got into a steeper-than-normal and never recovered, hitting the water
with fatal forces. He had no reserve and was not wearing a helmet. We
can't say whether the reserve or helmet had anything to do with its
outcome. Certainly a reserve would need to be deployed high enough to
act.
Table below originally compiled by Mike
Nowland, updated by Jeff Goin.
Accidents list
causal factors in the order of relevance. For example, a motor failure
may be the primary causal factor but, if it caused a fatal accident
there was also a handling error. A PPG is so slow that any normal
landing speed will almost never cause fatal injuries. Same is true with
turbulence. It's possible that a pilot could be hit with mother nature's
fury without warning, but darned unlikely--usually the air was known to
be bumpy.
|
Code |
Causal Factor |
|
Skill
Level |
|
|
SM
Wa
T
Ha
Mid
Col
O
MF |
Steep
Maneuvering
Water
Turbulence
Handling Error
Midair
Collision (wires, trees, etc.)
Other
Motor Failure |
|
StSup
St
PPG1
PPG2
PPG3
I |
Student, supervised by Instructor
Student, not being supervised
Learning but with at least 2 unassisted flights.
Fairly skilled and at least 25 unassisted flights.
Highly skilled and at least 100 unassisted flights.
Skill varies but usually is high PPG2 or PPG3. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Name |
Location |
Cause |
Pri
Cause |
Sec
Cause |
Year |
|
Unknown |
NY |
Spin |
Ha |
T |
1996 |
|
Didier Plisson |
France |
Low collapse and spin on prototype in competition |
Ha |
|
1996 |
|
Unknown |
Portugal |
Panic jump over ocean, being blown offshore |
W |
Ha |
1999 |
|
Jan Rowicki |
Illinois |
Low turn near buildings, mech turbulence |
Ha |
T |
2000 |
|
Dave Robicaux |
Florida |
Low acro, water |
Ha |
W |
2001 |
|
Unknown |
Grottemmare, Italy |
Water, low, engine out (Bob Olejar PPC list) |
Wa |
|
2001 |
|
Dave Flood |
California |
Suicide |
O |
|
2002 |
|
Wayne Hartshorn |
Kentucky |
Hit tree first flight, ok but unstrapped and fell |
Col |
|
2002 |
|
JDA Officer |
Japan |
Water |
Wa |
|
2002 |
|
Wally Shilts |
Ohio |
Low acro |
Ha |
|
2003 |
|
Hidemi Uemura |
Japan |
Water |
Wa |
|
2004 |
|
Unknown |
Quebec |
Student kept hands in brakes while reaching down for
seat. |
Ha |
|
2004 |
|
John Burnworth |
North Carolina |
Takeoff from residental street, hit wires |
Col |
|
2005 |
|
Joe Petrosian |
Ensenada, Mexico |
Low collapse, probably in turbulence |
T |
H |
2005 |
|
Del Skaret |
Leiper's Fork, TN |
Engine out, stall? On launch. Self-trained. |
Ha |
|
2006 |
|
Gerald B. Lutz |
Perrysburg, OH |
Student under radio control of an instructor; tow launch |
Ha |
|
2006 |
|
Carlos Cotoruelo ('Coto') |
France |
Unknown, low flying into headwind |
T |
|
2006 |
|
Col. Barton George |
Albuquerque, NM |
Mid-air collision, other pilot distracted, one high,
one low, |
Mid |
|
2006 |
|
Sergio Villamizar |
Wellington, FL |
Unknown, turbulence-related? Trike |
Wa |
T |
2006 |
|
Julius Gee |
UK |
Low level aerobatics (more
here) |
Ha |
|
2007 |
|
Mike Rish |
Indiana |
Flew into water, got out of harness, drowned swimming
to shore Kim Young Min owner of Korean
paramotor manufacturer N-Zin wing was tragically killed during a
speed race in Thailand. Initial reports suggest that his brake
handle was sucked into the prop causing his wing to enter an
unrecoverable spiral. |
Wa |
|
2007 |
|
Kim Young Min, owner of paramotor maker N-Zing |
Thailand |
killed during a "speed race" (cross country) in
Thailand. Initial reports suggest that his brake handle was sucked
into the prop causing his wing to enter an unrecoverable spiral. |
O |
|
2007 |
|
Kevin Rymer Craig |
UK |
High level acro w/ structural failure of paramotor (more
here) |
MF |
Ha |
2008 |
|
Martin Maxwell |
Monument Valley, AZ |
Flew towards mesa with distant thunderstorm. Trike. (more
here) |
T |
Ha |
2008 |
|
Unknown |
Florida |
Trike launch, went into water, drowned |
Wa |
|
2008 |
|
Tim Wyeth |
UK |
Turbulence at low level (more
here.) |
T |
|
2009 |
|
Unknown |
Florida |
Foot launched Tandem, couldn't reach brake toggle,
went into water, pilot drowned, wife survived (Not USPPA rated, don't know
if certified). |
Wa |
|
2009 |
|
Bill Crosby |
Arizona |
Caught tree limb on wheel of trike while maneuvering
steeply (more
here). |
Col |
SM |
2009 |
|
Andrew Azarskova |
IL |
Extended his launch run onto an adjoining road and
got hit by a truck. (added 6/14/2010) |
O |
|
2010 |
|
Mike Larronde |
TX |
Steep Spiral went nose over (vertical) and hit the
water with no obvious recovery effort. (added 9/17/2010) |
O |
|
2010 |
|
Wojtek Hewig |
Germany |
Induced collapse for purpose of testing wing.
Complications caused a cravat and resulting steep spiral. He had a
reserve but did not deploy it for unknown reasons. (added
11/30/2010) |
SM |
O |
2010 |
|
Unknown |
TX |
Student on trike flying DHV 1-2 wing under
instruction. Got into an oscillation. Instructor radioed hands up
but student continued inputs until impact (added
11/30/2010) |
Ha StSup |
O |
2011 |